Let's talk about gluttony
Last week, pastor Doug Wilson posted a video answering the question “What is gluttony?” in which he asserted that it is simply “riotous eating”—a problem which mostly applied to the bacchanalian food orgies of ancient history—and someone being overweight today could simply be a problem of their slow metabolism.
As expected, (especially given Wilson’s own size, which he acknowledges in the video) the response drew a lot of criticism and a firestorm of discussion on the topic of gluttony.
The sin of gluttony isn’t discussed much today, I believe because we simply don’t know what to do with it.
It’s hard to believe that in our world today, with such disordered relationships with food and where over 72% of Americans are overweight, that gluttony is not a sin we still need to be concerned about.
But we also know that metabolic disorders can significantly alter the normal signaling of the hunger hormone grehlin, that many overweight and unhealthy people have been sorely misled by poor advice, and that many of them are fighting hard, to little or no avail, to lose weight.

In a helpful response, pastor Brian Sauvé outlined Thomas Aquinas’ definition of the five types of gluttony. Understanding these different forms that the sin of gluttony can take is a great way to guide our eating, for righteousness and for health.
Praepropere (Hastily): Eating too soon, eating too fast, or starting to eat before it is appropriate or polite.
This first type of gluttony reminds us that food is an inextricable element of fellowship and hospitality, and it should be used appropriately to further those means.
It also tells us that there are times for eating and times for not eating.
A concept we see throughout the Bible and in God’s created order is rhythms. Summer and winter, work and rest, sleeping and wakefulness, feasting and fasting.
Nutritionally, I am not opposed to snacks and I take a reserved approach to fasting. Practicing OMAD (one meal a day) or consistently skipping breakfast is not good for metabolism, stress, or thyroid function. These kinds of practices will also, paradoxically, make losing weight much harder down the road. Many people are not metabolically in a position where fasting of any kind a net positive for them. Regardless, it is commanded in the Bible, but we shouldn’t be forcing it continually simply for health benefits.
On the other hand, eating constantly is a good way to rack up extra calories that will contribute to weight gain, and is usually not done for the purpose of satisfying a true appetite.
A concept I stress in my book is that true appetites (such as for carbohydrates, protein, fat, salt, water, or more calories; not appetites for specific junk foods) are signals our bodies give us for our health (unless our appetites have been altered by metabolic diseases, as mentioned earlier, or certain low-quality foods).
We can and should try to honor our real appetites. A good guide to doing so is to ask, “what will leave me feeling most satisfied?” Eating too much doesn’t leave one feeling satisfied, and neither does eating too little. Eating candy because it’s easy and available doesn’t leave one feeling satisfied if they really need some more protein.
But food is also most satisfying when it is eaten in response to some real hunger. It is good to let some real hunger develop before going for a snack or beginning to prepare a meal.
Laute (Sumptuously): Seeking out luxurious, costly, or extravagant foods that go beyond one's means or station.
I am a big advocate of finding deep enjoyment in God’s gift of food. We should seek out enjoyable foods, learn to prepare food better, and share it with others. Doing so, we can learn more about God’s goodness, provision, and creativity.

But we also need to be thankful and satisfied when dinner is beans and rice because that is all that can be afforded, or when a friend invites you over and serves microwave pizza, or when a recipe doesn’t turn out as well as we would have hoped.
I believe this concept can also apply to paying too much for high-quality foods. While I can make a strong case nutritionally and ethically (and do so in my book) for choosing organic, regenerative, pastured, grass-fed, etc, in many cases, it needs to be done with wise stewardship of your money. It’s also helpful to understand that the most impactful ways you can opt for high-quality foods are not decisions that will cost more money. Often, they actually save money, like making food yourself from scratch instead of buying pre-made.
Nimis (Excessively): Consuming too much in terms of sheer quantity, eating past the point of physical need or stomach capacity.
This is the type of gluttony we usually think of as gluttony.
Honoring real appetites, like discussed above, is one great way to avoid this.
There are several reasons one might be overeating in disregard to a real appetite. In the past, it might have been to gain weight in order to flaunt wealth. Today it may be for emotional reasons.
In these cases, people needed to evaluate their heart towards their image, and today, to how they are meeting emotional needs.
And if appetites have been hijacked by low-quality foods (like excess polyunsaturated fats that stimulate the endocannabinoid system the same way that cannabis does) or metabolic diseases, then a proper understanding of nutrition and some good old-fashioned self-control is in order.
Ardenter (Greedily): Eating too eagerly, with an intense, inordinate passion or obsession for the pleasure of the food itself.
This is the type of gluttony that Wilson seems to have been speaking to.
While we should enjoy food for the glory of God, there are ditches on the side of any road. Ardenter would be the ditch of forgetting what our enjoyment of foods should ultimately point to (God) or just plain dishonoring the people eating around us by acting like a pig.

Studiose (Daintily / Fastidiously): Being overly particular, fussy, or demanding about how food is prepared, seasoned, or sourced.
This last type of gluttony is paradoxical to our common, simple understanding of gluttony, but so important to understand.
Today, this might surface most commonly in people holding too rigidly to a strict diet:
The person who cannot accept a dinner invitation because they do not know what will be in the food. The person who must tell everyone their diet identity and demand they provide foods that meet their standards. The person you know you can’t share a birthday cake with because they would accept it, but then fret and stress and feel guilty about it afterwards.
The thing is, eating healthy does not require you follow a diet that ostracizes you from normal fellowship, community, and celebrations. And not because I advocate some kind of 80/20 rule so that you can exist in the real world—because a healthy diet isn’t about cutting out whole food groups or macronutrients, or even foods. It’s simply about choosing high quality versions of every kind of food that is already out there, when you can.
Of course there are specific health conditions that call for more particular diets, but these usually only need to be temporary, and they never call for fussing or turning your diet into your identity.
______________________________________________________
There’s no need to shy away from the concept of gluttony. In today’s world we can—and need to—face it head on. A good understanding of gluttony is a wonderful foundation for guiding our approach to health, for righteousness and for health.


Comments